Guest column: You’re against racism or for it, there’s no third side
“All lives do not matter. But all lives should.”
June 5, 2020
Editors’ note: This column, written by 2020 graduate Aerica McIntosh, contains a sensitive word.
The first time I remember experiencing racism was when I was about 5. A little girl pushed me off the top of a slide, telling me she hated “coons.” I told my mom I didn’t know what that meant, and the next day I sat with the girl in timeout. I thought we were friends.
When I was about 8 years old, I came outside to see that someone had scratched the word “nigger” into our car. Comparatively, that was only a minor offense, but it was still difficult to process as a kid.
As I got older I experienced the basic racism: being followed in stores, being called the n-word, people locking their doors as I passed, etc.
My sophomore year after one of my first school dances at Maize, I came outside to see the police at the far end of the parking lot. My friends and I just thought it was someone who was caught speeding. I texted my mom repeatedly asking where she is. She responded with one word.
“Police.”
I immediately started walking over to her with my friend following just to make sure I was safe — an example of someone using their privilege for good. I got in the car and placed my hands on the dash.
“What are you doing in this neighborhood?” the officer asked, to which my mom replied that she is picking me up from the school dance. She repeatedly asked why she was pulled over. We were told it was a routine stop.
This is one story of many first-hand experiences with racism and discrimination. In the last few years, we have been stopped more than 10 times. When we see the police, we aren’t just scared of getting in trouble. We are scared our lives may be in danger over something trivial.
To this day, my mother forces my siblings and me to follow strict rules in public to lessen the amount of times we are followed and questioned in stores.
“Keep your hands out of your pocket.”
“Take your hood off inside.”
“Don’t touch stuff that you don’t intend on buying.”
“Avoid any tense conversation with people in public to avoid altercations escalating.”
I am to always be hyper aware of the color of my skin.
Over time, all of these small things start to make you feel as though you are “less than,” not even a person. I have always felt like I was someone left out of a cruel joke because of the color of my skin.
But I am not my skin. I am a person who deserves to be treated like one.
Black Lives Matter isn’t just a cry for murder to stop. It is a cry for overall equality. Black people face hundreds of problems that stem from racial inequality: redlining, job disparities, astronomical incarceration rates, food deserts, healthcare inequality, unequal schooling and funds. The list goes on for miles.
There are two sides to everything. If you aren’t siding with this movement or its beliefs, then your side is racism. There is no way to deny it. Black lives matter, have value and should be treated as such.
This movement is not debatable. Human rights are not debatable. This movement is not a trend. The lives shouldn’t only matter when they have ended and turn up as a top 10 hashtag. This is not something that should pop up only when an innocent black life is taken and becomes viral. This is something that should infiltrate the system and foundation of the racist country we live in.
Fact of the matter is, all lives do not matter and will not matter until black lives do. I must repeat: All lives do not matter. But all lives should.
How come anytime someone says that black lives matter you come rushing in to defend the others. They do not need defending. No one ever said they didn’t matter. If your immediate response to the BLM movement is all lives matter, then you may need to reevaluate where you stand.
That phrase completely disrespects, devalues and contradicts the lives of black Americans everywhere. All lives matter shows the delusion of equality that people still hold and is a clear indication that people are blind and must educate themselves.
The blatant disregard for the movement should be sufficient enough evidence to show you why they do not matter. BLM is not just simply something you utter when an unarmed black man is killed by the police. Tell me, when you see names like Treyvon Martin, Tamir Rice, Emmett Till, teenagers — black teenagers — do you sit there and wonder what would have happened if that were you?
Black lives matter is a way to hone in on the important issue here: police brutality and racial inequality, not to exclude. If you want to prove all lives matter then start showing it.
Don’t devalue the voice and outrage of black individuals because you want to be included in a movement. Support the one that is existing and be happy that your identity doesn’t need a revolution.
I encourage you all to use your privilege. I encourage you to educate yourself daily. I encourage you to be actively anti-racist.
Sherilyn Fahlstrom • Jun 12, 2020 at 7:39 am
First of all, I’m so sorry Aerica. Sorry that you have experienced racism. Secondly, thank you. Thank you for your simple, real examples that help me understand. I want to understand. Black lives matter. You matter.
TraceAnn Adkins • Jun 7, 2020 at 9:04 pm
For anyone saying ‘I don’t see color ” is further devaluing the racial strife going on. Of course you see color, celebrate the beautiful differences in our appearances. Instead say, I work to not have preconceived ideas about people based on race.
Racism is so deeply ingrained in our society, we all know black people are treated differently, but who told us that? We just know, black men are seen as threatening, black women seen as angry. How do white people ever feel comfortable telling a person of color their experiences are wrong or exaggerated? My multi racial daughter is followed in stores, asked if she’s adopted, told she talks and acts white, but is still too black e to be allowed to date white boys at a private high school. I could write pages on the incidents my husband faced as a black man in a white man’s world. Horrid racist attacks his whole life. I told him how upset I’d be ‘if’ someone called our child a racial slur, he told me not if, but when. He was correct, I’ve been told to support my own race, called nigg@r lover and more. Told it was wrong to bring a child into my mixed marriage as the child would never fit in, alternatively I’ve been told how racism is over or things are so better now. Yes we have civil right laws, but that doesn’t change an individual’s heart, if not applied equally laws mean nothing. When a white person says slavery is over, it shows the failure of our education system to teach America’s history. We go from protests to MLK saying nice words, Rosa Parks sitting on a bus then the civl civl rights act. We gloss over slavery, Jim Crowe laws, systemic racism in housing, lending, schools, court system etc. The Tulsa riots, the system of separate but equal providing a divide that lingers. How is it possible that black Americans are 14% of thr population yet are 38% of the prison population. For those if you who say more white people are killed by the police, it should stand that way, there are more white people, the percentage of black people killed by police is disproportionate to the number of black citizens there are What about the the open hatred shown Obama, senators plotting to block everything in his presidency at his inauguration? There are people who point to Obama as an example of racism being over… but think, Obama’s mom was white from Kansas, but society sees him a black man. The same society that sees my daughter as black and constantly asks me who I am when I’m with her. A school secretary told a mutual friend that she was so surprised when she met me, I was so well spoken and educated. Our mutual friend asked her why that surprised her. She answered, “well you know she’s married to a black man” yes a black man who spoke 4 languages, had traveled the world, college graduate, never been in prison or a gang, but judged harshly just the same.
It’s not enough anymore to not be racist, it is time to understand our history, know what POC go thru, admit our prejudices. It’s time to be anti racist
Edith Graham • Jun 6, 2020 at 6:00 pm
Thank you for writing this excellent article. Great voice!!! More people need to hear our truth. People don’t understand our walk because they don’t have to live it. Congratulations on your graduation. I know you will go on to do more great things. God’s speed to you.
P. Richmond • Jun 6, 2020 at 5:45 pm
I would love to think that the new awareness of racism and injustice is a road leading to resolution, where people of all colors will be able to exist in peace. Live up to that “with liberty and justice for and justice for all.” For those who still refuse to believe these experiences, so many are expressing, I hope you never endure 1 ounce of the frustrations among other things black people have endured. The stories shared only for enlightenment, not sympathy. I as a black woman am not asking to treated just, I am demanding to be treated just, no differently than any other citizen of this country. Sad this is still a conversation needed in 2020. Young lady you come from strong people, walk with your head high and shoulders back!
Raina Harper • Jun 6, 2020 at 11:50 am
Those are great words! No one should have to feel less than the person you are beside! So so wrong! My heart goes out to you!!
Jim Donecker • Jun 6, 2020 at 8:11 am
Aerica, you are so brave to speak not only for yourself and community, but also for all of the brave men and women who never over these awful racial filled years were given the opportunity to speak up or even live! Thank you so much.
Tishayln Jacobs • Jun 6, 2020 at 12:55 am
You go girl. This article is so well written. I’m so glad you spoke up and shared your story. It breaks my heart that you’ve had to experience so much hate in your life. I love how you said all lives dont matter but they should. Beautiful. Thank you for this article. Congratulations on the accomplishment of graduating.
Take care,
❤
Deb Wolf • Jun 6, 2020 at 12:22 am
Aerica,
This is incredibly well written and thought out. Awesome job. Your message is comprehensive and educational, it is messages like this that will become the bedrock of change.
Mrs. Wolf
Joanna Cramb • Jun 6, 2020 at 12:06 am
Aerica, thank you. Your words, experiences, pain and, unfortunately, racism really affected me. I shared your article on Facebook and earnestly asked for each and every one of my friends and family to please read it. You are a very intelligent, beautiful young lady, who is also black. I wish and pray often that others will see ALL of an individual’s qualities first and not just color. You do have a beautiful soul and have a gift of writing 😊. Thank you for sharing your private struggles with racism. Much love to you and your family ❤️
Johnna Kolar • Jun 5, 2020 at 11:07 pm
Aerica,
Thank you for sharing your story and letting us get a glimpse of what life has been like for you and your family over the years. I am sorry for the pain you all have endured. Your powerful words really resonated with me. I am so proud of you for sharing your thoughts with us. You are already proving you are making a change in the world!
Love,
Mrs. K
Callie Harris • Jun 5, 2020 at 9:26 pm
Thank you for sharing your story. My heartbreaks that these are lessons we still have to learn in 2020. Your words are powerful! Keep speaking the truth! We are listening.
Teresa Lewis • Jun 5, 2020 at 9:20 pm
Well said, America! I appreciate your honesty and your boldness. Thanks so much for sharing your story here. Congratulations on your graduation! Good luck as your journey continues. I hope it includes writing!
Sandy Tope • Jun 5, 2020 at 8:59 pm
Your words are powerful.
Thank you!!!
Nancy Boothe • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:51 pm
Aerica,
Thank you for sharing your experiences. I am so sorry for all the distrust, suspicion, and hatred you have gone through. You are absolutely right. It is unjust, unfair, wrong, and wicked. I’m a white grandma who promises you I will listen more, read more, and become more vocal about anti-racism. Over my lifetime I’ve been vaguely aware, but never really grasping what white privilege meant. I think I have a good heart, but it has to be a lot more than that in order to turn this ship around. I don’t know exactly how to make a difference, but I’m asking the Lord for opportunities.
I appreciate your words! God bless.
Rhonda O’Neill • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:45 pm
Very well said. Thank you for sharing your painful story and trying to help others understand. Unfortunately, some people don’t want to understand.
My daughter is a junior at MHS and she has spoken up for BLM and has been called out by some of her friends, but she won’t give up, or be silenced.
Know that there are people who live in the Maize community who are fighting for BLM and for change.
Lisa Kilmer • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:37 pm
Bravo Aerica! Keep speaking truth to power.
Chess Ponds • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:29 pm
Aerica I am oh soooooooooo very proud of you! You are bomb and brave for speaking your mind and taking a stand for our black community. You’ve Made me proud in so many ways. Way to not be afraid or back down. Majorities don’t realize the microscope we are under on a daily just solely based on our skin color. Thank you Kidd. ❤️U!
Janet Delanty • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:22 pm
Thank you sharing your life of living with racism. I cannot understand what you have experienced. I lived in Maize in the 90’s and my son was educated there. I had hoped we were better than that. More needs to be done on making Black Lives matter so truly all lives will matter.
You should consider writing. Congrats on being your graduation! Continue to make a difference as you have here. Blessings to you & your family as you move forward on your next journey.
Bethany Janssen • Jun 5, 2020 at 7:21 pm
Thank you for speaking for truths that have always existed. I applaud you for your courage as a student in a fairly homogeneous school. Your white peers need to hear the reality of what you go through on a daily basis! We all need to do better! Black Lives Matter
Beth Janssen
MHS art teacher
One Proud Momma • Jun 5, 2020 at 6:09 pm
Such eloquent truths. Thank you, for sharing! I love you and am SO proud of you!
Keith jansen • Jun 5, 2020 at 6:07 pm
This was a very well thought out opinion and article.
I’m sorry you and your family have had to go through this trip of profiling. Sure it happens a lot and not just with you. I guess I have never really thought about it in terms like simply going to the store because I don’t see color and never will. I just see someone going to get something they need or want. Seems like you have a very beautiful soul and maybe should think about writing for a living.
God bless!!!